Updated November 2026 · By Alex Martin, MapX
The short answer: use talent mapping software if you run senior roles regularly and have someone on the team to drive it. Use a talent mapping firm for one-off, high-stakes or confidential projects, or when you need researchers to speak to people in the market. Many in-house teams now do both: software for day-to-day searches and market questions, with research support bought in for the hardest roles.
We make MapX, which is software with an optional research service, so this guide sets out the trade-offs plainly, including where a firm is the better choice.
What a talent mapping firm does
Talent mapping firms include specialist research firms, the research teams inside executive search firms, and some RPO providers. A typical project:
- agrees a brief and a list of target companies
- builds org charts and a list of named leaders through desk research
- often calls people in the market to confirm structures, interest and pay
- delivers a report, usually within a few weeks
Firms usually charge per project or per day. The value is in judgement, primary research and doing the work for you.
What talent mapping software does
Talent mapping software gives your team the data and tools to do the research in-house. Good platforms for senior roles:
- build target company lists, including adjacent sectors
- find leaders by function and seniority rather than job title
- size the talent pool and show where people sit
- rank leaders against a brief
- produce reports you can share with hiring managers
Software is usually sold as an annual licence. The value is speed, cost per search and the fact that your team owns the knowledge.
Side by side
- Speed: a firm usually takes a few weeks per project. Software takes hours once the team is trained.
- Cost model: firms charge per project or per day. Software is an annual licence used on every role.
- Market conversations: firms' researchers call people. Software is desk research only, unless a research service is added.
- Effort from your team: low with a firm (brief and review). Medium with software (someone runs the searches).
- Confidentiality: a firm suits sensitive projects run at arm's length. With software, research stays inside your team.
- Reuse: a firm delivers a report per project. With software, maps and company lists build up over time.
- Best for: firms suit one-off or very sensitive work. Software suits regular senior hiring and market questions.
When software is the better fit
- You run several senior searches or talent questions a quarter.
- Hiring managers want to see the market early, before a brief is final.
- You want to reduce reliance on search firms for the research stage.
- You need answers in days, not weeks.
When a firm is the better fit
- It's a one-off project in a market you rarely hire in.
- You need people in the market to be called to test interest, pay or structure.
- The project is highly confidential, such as replacing a sitting executive.
- Your team has no capacity at all to run research.
When to use both
A common pattern is software for most searches, with research support for the few roles that need conversations or extra validation. This keeps costs predictable while still covering the hard cases. MapX works this way: the software is the core licence, and 6 Group researchers can validate a map or run outreach and screening on a specific role when you need it. See our research services page for how that works.
Questions to ask a talent mapping firm
- How do you build the target company list, and can we change it?
- How much of the work is desk research and how much is calls?
- How do you present findings to hiring managers?
- Do we own the data and the report afterwards?
- How long will it take, and what's the cost if the brief changes?
Questions to ask a software vendor
- Does it search on function and seniority, or only job titles?
- How good is the data for senior leaders in our key countries?
- Can it build target company lists from a brief, including adjacent sectors?
- How long does it take to go from a brief to a shareable report?
- Is there help available when we need research support?
How to do this on MapX in minutes
MapX gives an in-house team the research a firm would deliver, in about an hour, with researchers on hand for the roles that need conversations.
- Set the brief and the target companies in Polaris, starting from your own lists, MapX's 2m+ companies, or both.
- Mark the must-haves and weight the rest. Must-haves are checked separately, so a high score can't hide a missing requirement.
- Review the market map: every relevant leader, the numbers at each step, and why each exclusion was made.
- Add people where they help. Use research credits for validated mapping, or for outreach and screening on the roles that need it.
The result is the firm-style deliverable, in your brand, owned by your team and reusable on the next role.
Frequently asked questions
What is a talent mapping company?
A firm that researches a market for you: it identifies the companies and leaders relevant to a role or question and reports back, often including conversations with people in the market.
How long does a talent map take?
A firm typically takes a few weeks. With software built for executive roles, a full market map can take about an hour. In MapX, a first search runs in under 15 minutes.
Is talent mapping software cheaper than a firm?
If you run senior roles regularly, usually yes, because one licence covers every role. For a single one-off project, a firm can cost less overall.
Can AI replace talent mapping firms?
AI can now do most of the desk research: finding companies and leaders and ranking them against a brief. It can't replace conversations with people in the market or the judgement of an experienced researcher on a sensitive project.
What to do next
To compare the output for yourself, the MapX sample pack has example market maps and shortlists using fictional data. You can also book a free 30-minute session and bring a role you'd normally send to a firm. For more on choosing software, read our practitioner's guide to talent mapping software.